What is bona fide possession? How does it differ from mala fide possesion?

In this article, let’s find out what is bona fide possession and distinguish between bona fide vs mala fide possession with PL & Partners Law Firm

In the Civil Code 2015, there are two terms bona fide possession (possession in good faith) and mala fide possession (possession in bad faith). In fact, in many cases, it is not easy to distinguish between good faith and bad faith.

So how can we distinguish which cases are considered to be bona fide possession and which are mala fide possession? Please find out with PL & Partners through the following article.

Chiếm hữu ngay tình là gì? Làm thế nào để phân biệt được chiếm hữu ngay tình và không ngay tình?

What is bona fide possession? How to distinguish bona fide and mala fide possession?

1. WHAT IS BONA FIDE POSSESSION?

Previously, pursuant to Article 189 of the Civil Code 2005 (which has expired), bona fide possession was defined as follows:

“A person possessing property without a legal basis but in good faith is a possessor who does not know and cannot know that the possession of such property has no legal basis”.

Currently, pursuant to Article 180 of the Civil Code 2015, it is defined as:

“Bona fide possession is possession in which the possessor has grounds to believe that he or she has the right to the property being possessed.”

Thus, compared with the old provisions in the Civil Code 2005, the Civil Code 2015 has a more specific definition of bona fide possession. You only need grounds to believe that you have the right to the property being possessed to be considered as a possessor in good faith.

For example:

Mr. A owed Mr. B and was sued in court. Mr. A’s land was used to pay Mr. B.

After that, Mr. A’s land was sold and transferred to Ms. C in accordance with regulations on judgment enforcement.

So Ms.C is the bona fide possessor. The ground for her bona fide possession is the certificate of land use right which has her name on it.

"<yoastmark

Contrary to bona fide possession is mala fide possession defined in Article 181 of the Civil Code 2015: “Mala fide possession is possession that the possessor knows or ought to know that he or she has no right to the property being possessed.”

2. DISTINGUISH BETWEEN BONA FIDE AND MALA FIDE POSSESSION.

Criterias

Bona fide possession Mala fide possession
Legal basis Article 180 Civil Code 2015 Article 181 Civil Code 2015
Essence The possessor has grounds to believe that he/she holds title to the property under his/her possession.

The possessor did not know or could not know that his/her possession had no legal basis.

The possessor knew or should have known that he/she has no legal basis to possess the property.
Legal consequences To become the owner of the property if the possession is in good faith, continuous, overt, and the owner cannot be identified within:

– 10 years: for movable (personal property);

– 30 years: for real estate.

Not to become the owner of the property, but to return the property to its holder, and to pay damages, if any, caused by the act of illegal possession.

Determining whether the possession is in good faith or not is important in:

  • Establishing the ownership to the property being possessed;
  • Protecting the bona fide possessor on possessing the property;
  • Protecting the legitimate rights and interests of the real owner of the property.

___________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Thus, PL & Partners Law Firm has shared with you about bona fide, mala fide possession and how to distinguish between the two.

Hope the above information will be useful to you.


If you need further legal assistance, please contact us at:       

PL AND PARTNERS LAW FIRM

Headquarters: 46th Floor, Bitexco Financial Tower, No. 2 Hai Trieu, Ben Nghe Ward, District 1, Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam

Office: Lot 1.16 Viva Riverside, 1472 Vo Van Kiet, Ward 3, District 6, HCMC

Hotline: 093.1111.060

Email: info@pl-partners.vn

Facebook: www.facebook.com/PLLaw

Website: www.PL-PARTNERS.vnwww.HOIDAPLUAT.netwww.THUTUCPHAPLY.org

We are always ready to assist you.


The article is based on the applicable law at the time of writing and may no longer be appropriate at the time you read it due to changes in laws. Therefore, the article is for reference only.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

SCHEDULE AN APPOINTMENT




























    Tagged: none tag .

    Related post: